Pappas Pies

Pies, Cakes , & More

Call 219-662-7900 now to order your freshly baked Pie, Pasty, or Cake. 

Pies

Apple Pie

$14.99

Banana Cream

$15.99

Banana Strawberry Cream

$15.99

Bavarian Chocolate Cream

$15.99

Blueberry Pie

$14.99

Boston Cream

$15.99

Cherry Cream

$15.99

Cherry Pie

$14.99

Chocolate Crunch Cream

$15.99

Coconut Cream

$15.99

Dutch Apple

$14.99

Irish Cream

$15.99

Key Lime

$15.99

Oreo Cream

$15.99

Peach Pie

$14.99

Pecan Pie

$14.99

Pineapple Cream

$15.99

Pumpkin Pie

$11.99

Strawberry Cream

$15.99

Cakes

Black Forest Cake

$24.99

Carmella Mousse Cake

$24.99

Carrot Cake

$24.99

Cheesecake - Pumpkin Whole

$34.99

Cheesecake - Vanilla Whole

$29.99

Chocolate Boston Cake

$24.99

German Chocolate Cake

$24.99

Lemon Cake

$24.99

Oreo Cake

$24.99

Raspberry Cake

$24.99

Raspberry Choc Mousse Cake

$24.99

Tiramisu Cake

$24.99

White Chocolate Mousse Cake

$24.99

Specialty

Baklava

$48.99

Rice Pudding - 1/2 Gallon

$14.99